Top 10 Time and Attendance Software: Features, Pros, Cons and Comparison

---

Introduction

Time and attendance software helps organizations record working hours, manage shifts and attendance exceptions, apply labor policies, and produce payroll-ready data. In simple terms, it answers: When did people start work, when did they end, did they take breaks correctly, and do we have exceptions that require approval? These tools reduce manual errors, improve fairness, and help payroll teams stop chasing corrections every cycle.

This category matters because attendance data impacts payroll accuracy, compliance, labor costs, and workforce trust. Without a good system, managers handle timecards in spreadsheets, employees dispute hours, and payroll teams lose time fixing inconsistencies. A strong time and attendance platform makes time capture easy, enforces policies consistently, and provides clear audit-friendly records.

Real-world use cases:

• Clock-in and clock-out for hourly teams across locations
• Break tracking and overtime rule handling concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Manager approvals for missed punches and exceptions
• Payroll-ready exports and pay code reporting
• Compliance support through timesheet locking and audit trail concepts

What buyers should evaluate before choosing:

• Time capture options (mobile, web, kiosk, biometrics concepts, geofencing concepts)
• Policy rules (break compliance, overtime, rounding, shift differentials concepts)
• Exception handling workflows (missed punches, edits, approvals, audit trail concepts)
• Scheduling integration (shift planning, rostering, coverage)
• Payroll readiness (exports, pay codes, approval cycles, locking)
• Employee self-service (view timecards, request edits, see schedules)
• Reporting (overtime trends, attendance, tardiness, exception volume)
• Integrations (HR, payroll, identity, ERP, POS, devices, APIs)
• Administration and governance (roles, permissions, multi-location controls)
• Adoption and usability (simple punch flows and clear timecard views)

Best for: organizations with hourly work, multiple locations, strict labor policies, or payroll complexity that requires consistent time capture and approvals.
Not ideal for: small salaried teams with flexible hours and minimal policy enforcement needs, where basic time tracking may be enough.

---

Key Trends in Time and Attendance Software

• More mobile-first clocking to support distributed and field teams
• Stronger employee self-service to reduce manager overhead
• Better automation for exceptions, approvals, and timecard corrections
• Increased demand for audit-friendly change history and locked pay periods
• More real-time alerts for overtime risk and break violations
• Greater integration with payroll and HR to eliminate duplicate entry
• More support for multi-location permission boundaries and role-based access
• Increased use of kiosks and device integrations depending on industry
• Stronger reporting for attendance patterns and labor cost signals
• Higher emphasis on fairness and transparency to improve workforce trust

---

How We Selected These Tools

• Strong adoption for time and attendance capture and approvals
• Practical exception handling, policy enforcement, and payroll exports
• Coverage across workforce-heavy industries and office environments
• Integration readiness with payroll and HR ecosystems
• Mix of enterprise suites and scheduling-first platforms
• Emphasis on usability for employees and managers

---

Top 10 Time and Attendance Software

1 — UKG Pro Workforce Management

UKG Pro Workforce Management is widely used for enterprise time and attendance with strong labor rule handling and exception workflows. It fits multi-location operations with complex policies.

Key Features

• Time capture with exception workflows and approvals (Varies / N/A)
• Labor rule configuration for breaks and overtime concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Timecard corrections with audit trail concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service for timecards and requests (Varies / N/A)
• Alerts for exceptions and compliance signals (Varies / N/A)
• Payroll-ready exports and reporting concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Multi-location governance and role-based access concepts (Varies / N/A)

Pros

• Strong labor rules and exception handling for complex operations
• Good governance for multi-location workforce environments

Cons

• Configuration can be detailed and time-consuming
• Requires disciplined processes to keep policies consistent

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud (Varies / N/A)

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often integrated with HR and payroll systems and time capture devices.

• Payroll and HR integrations (Varies / N/A)
• Device and kiosk ecosystem support (Varies / N/A)
• APIs for reporting and workflow automation (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Enterprise support model. Training and policy ownership strongly impact success.

---

2 — UKG Ready

UKG Ready supports time and attendance for mid-sized organizations needing structured approvals, policies, and payroll-friendly reporting. It fits teams that need practical controls without heavy enterprise complexity.

Key Features

• Time capture with attendance exception handling (Varies / N/A)
• Manager approvals for edits and corrections concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Policy rules for overtime and break compliance concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service for timecards and requests (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting for overtime, attendance, and exceptions (Varies / N/A)
• Payroll-ready exports and pay code concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for multi-team workforce operations

Pros

• Good balance of timekeeping controls and usability
• Practical manager workflows for timecard approvals

Cons

• Advanced enterprise labor optimization may be limited
• Reporting depth depends on configuration and plan

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud (Varies / N/A)

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often connects to payroll and HR workflows to reduce rework.

• Payroll and HR ecosystem alignment (Varies / N/A)
• Exports and integrations depend on environment (Varies / N/A)
• APIs and connectors vary by plan (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Support tiers vary. Adoption improves with clear timecard rules and training.

---

3 — ADP Workforce Now

ADP Workforce Now is widely used where time and attendance must connect directly to payroll processing and HR workflows. It fits teams prioritizing payroll accuracy and structured approvals.

Key Features

• Time and attendance workflows with approvals concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Exception handling and timecard corrections patterns (Varies / N/A)
• Payroll-aligned exports and reporting concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Policy rules for labor and attendance concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Manager dashboards for exceptions and attendance signals (Varies / N/A)
• Role-based access for managers and HR teams (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for payroll-focused operations

Pros

• Strong payroll alignment and structured processing workflows
• Practical exception handling and approvals for managers

Cons

• Scheduling depth and advanced analytics may vary by configuration
• Custom reporting may require careful setup

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud (Varies / N/A)

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often selected when attendance data must flow reliably into payroll operations.

• Payroll ecosystem integrations (Varies / N/A)
• Exports and reporting pipelines vary by plan (Varies / N/A)
• APIs and connectors depend on configuration (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Enterprise support orientation. Clear policies and training improve data quality.

---

4 — Workday Time Tracking

Workday Time Tracking is used when time and attendance workflows must align with core HR governance and approvals. It fits organizations already using Workday for HR processes.

Key Features

• Time entry and approvals tied to HR concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Policy validations and exception workflows (Varies / N/A)
• Manager review flows and escalation patterns (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service for timecards and requests (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting for attendance and labor signals (Varies / N/A)
• Role-based permissions aligned to HR governance (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for standardized HR-led operations

Pros

• Strong alignment between time workflows and HR governance
• Consistent approvals and reporting across teams

Cons

• Can be heavy for teams needing only basic time clocks
• Configuration complexity depends on policy requirements

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud (Varies / N/A)

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often used as part of a broader HR and payroll environment.

• Integrations depend on Workday configuration (Varies / N/A)
• Exports and connectors vary by setup (Varies / N/A)
• APIs support reporting and workflow automation (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Enterprise support model. Best outcomes require strong governance ownership and training.

---

5 — SAP SuccessFactors

SAP SuccessFactors supports time management concepts and attendance workflows aligned to enterprise HR governance. It fits organizations standardizing policies and approvals across large workforces.

Key Features

• Workforce time management concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Attendance approvals and exception handling patterns (Varies / N/A)
• Policy controls for labor rules concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting aligned to HR and workforce analytics (Varies / N/A)
• Role-based access for managers and HR teams (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service workflows (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for HR-led policy standardization

Pros

• Strong HR governance alignment and standardized controls
• Useful reporting when workforce policies must be consistent

Cons

• Implementation can be complex depending on scope
• May be heavy for teams needing lightweight time clocks only

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud (Varies / N/A)

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often used in enterprise HR environments where standardized employee data is critical.

• HR and ERP integrations vary by organization (Varies / N/A)
• Exports depend on configuration (Varies / N/A)
• APIs support automation and reporting pipelines (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Enterprise support orientation. Adoption improves with clear policies and training.

---

6 — Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM

Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM supports attendance and workforce time concepts connected to enterprise HR and finance operations. It fits organizations needing consistent governance and reporting across departments.

Key Features

• Time and attendance concepts tied to workforce governance (Varies / N/A)
• Approvals and exception handling workflows (Varies / N/A)
• Policy controls for labor rules concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting for labor costs and attendance signals (Varies / N/A)
• Role-based access and multi-department controls (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service workflows (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for enterprise reporting and governance alignment

Pros

• Strong fit for enterprise governance and reporting consistency
• Useful alignment with broader business systems

Cons

• Can be complex for smaller teams
• Configuration effort depends on labor policy complexity

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud (Varies / N/A)

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often chosen when workforce time data must connect to enterprise operations.

• ERP and HR integrations vary (Varies / N/A)
• Exports and reporting depend on configuration (Varies / N/A)
• APIs support automation workflows (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Enterprise support model. Implementation partners and internal enablement are important.

---

7 — Ceridian Dayforce

Ceridian Dayforce is used for time and attendance workflows where exception handling, policy control, and payroll readiness matter. It fits organizations needing strong daily operational controls.

Key Features

• Attendance capture and timecard workflows (Varies / N/A)
• Exception handling and approvals patterns (Varies / N/A)
• Labor rule configuration for compliance concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting for overtime, attendance, and exceptions (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service for timecards and requests (Varies / N/A)
• Manager dashboards for operational oversight (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for reducing payroll corrections with cleaner time data

Pros

• Strong exception workflows and policy control for attendance data
• Helpful dashboards for overtime and compliance risk visibility

Cons

• Configuration can be detailed depending on labor rules
• Best results require consistent workforce policies

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud (Varies / N/A)

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often used where attendance data must feed payroll reliably.

• Integrations vary by environment (Varies / N/A)
• Export pipelines depend on configuration (Varies / N/A)
• APIs support reporting and automation (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Enterprise support orientation. Adoption improves with training and clear approval rules.

---

8 — BambooHR

BambooHR supports time tracking and attendance concepts in HR-friendly workflows, depending on configuration. It fits small-to-mid teams that want attendance data connected to HR records and approvals.

Key Features

• Time tracking and attendance concepts tied to HR workflows (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service for time entries and requests (Varies / N/A)
• Manager approvals and timecard oversight patterns (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting for attendance and workforce signals (Varies / N/A)
• Role-based access aligned to HR needs (Varies / N/A)
• Payroll alignment concepts depending on environment (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for HR-led teams wanting simpler workflows

Pros

• Friendly HR-focused experience for small and mid teams
• Good self-service patterns that reduce admin overhead

Cons

• Advanced labor rules and complex scheduling may be limited
• Deep enterprise controls may require workforce suites

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often used with payroll and HR operations tools to keep employee data consistent.

• Integrations vary by business stack (Varies / N/A)
• Export workflows depend on payroll environment (Varies / N/A)
• APIs and connectors vary by plan (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Support depends on plan. Best results come from simple policies and consistent usage.

---

9 — Deputy

Deputy is commonly used for time and attendance plus scheduling in shift-based operations. It fits teams that want quick adoption, mobile clock-ins, and simple approvals for attendance exceptions.

Key Features

• Mobile time capture and attendance workflows (Varies / N/A)
• Scheduling integration for shift teams (Varies / N/A)
• Manager approvals for exceptions and corrections concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Break and overtime rule concepts depending on setup (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service for schedules and timecards (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting for attendance and coverage signals (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for multi-location shift teams needing speed

Pros

• Fast adoption and strong mobile experience for shift teams
• Helpful self-service for schedules and attendance visibility

Cons

• Advanced enterprise labor rules may be limited
• Deep HR governance needs may require larger platforms

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often paired with payroll and operational systems depending on industry needs.

• Integrations vary by environment (Varies / N/A)
• Export workflows depend on payroll stack (Varies / N/A)
• APIs and connectors vary by plan (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Typically easy onboarding. Support tiers vary by plan.

---

10 — When I Work

When I Work supports attendance tracking alongside scheduling and team communication. It fits shift-based teams needing simple clock-ins, manager approvals, and clear schedule communication.

Key Features

• Time clock and attendance capture concepts (Varies / N/A)
• Scheduling integration and shift templates (Varies / N/A)
• Manager approvals and exception handling patterns (Varies / N/A)
• Employee self-service for schedules and timecards (Varies / N/A)
• Messaging for schedule and attendance coordination (Varies / N/A)
• Reporting for attendance and hours trends (Varies / N/A)
• Useful for teams that want straightforward workflows

Pros

• Simple workflows that teams adopt quickly
• Helpful communication features for shift coordination

Cons

• Advanced labor rule handling and forecasting may be limited
• Deep enterprise governance may require larger suites

Platforms / Deployment

• Platform(s): Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)
• Deployment: Cloud

Security and Compliance
Not publicly stated

Integrations and Ecosystem
Often used with payroll tools depending on business needs.

• Integrations vary by environment (Varies / N/A)
• Export workflows depend on payroll setup (Varies / N/A)
• APIs and automation options vary (Varies / N/A)

Support and Community
Support depends on plan. Adoption improves with clear timecard rules and manager routines.

---

Comparison Table

Tool Name	Best For	Platform(s) Supported	Deployment (Cloud/Self-hosted/Hybrid)	Standout Feature	Public Rating
UKG Pro Workforce Management	Enterprise labor rules and exception workflows	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud (Varies / N/A)	Strong labor rule handling	N/A
UKG Ready	Mid-sized time and attendance with structured controls	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud (Varies / N/A)	Balanced usability plus controls	N/A
ADP Workforce Now	Payroll-aligned attendance approvals and exports	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud (Varies / N/A)	Payroll-ready processing alignment	N/A
Workday Time Tracking	HR-governed time workflows for Workday environments	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud (Varies / N/A)	HR governance alignment	N/A
SAP SuccessFactors	Enterprise HR-aligned attendance and policies	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud (Varies / N/A)	HR policy standardization	N/A
Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM	Enterprise governance and workforce reporting	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud (Varies / N/A)	Enterprise controls and reporting	N/A
Ceridian Dayforce	Attendance exception handling with payroll readiness	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud (Varies / N/A)	Operational exception workflows	N/A
BambooHR	HR-friendly time and attendance for smaller teams	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud	HR-connected self-service workflows	N/A
Deputy	Shift team attendance plus scheduling integration	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud	Mobile-first shift workflows	N/A
When I Work	Simple time clock and scheduling for shift teams	Web, iOS, Android (Varies / N/A)	Cloud	Scheduling plus communication patterns	N/A

---

Evaluation and Scoring of Time and Attendance Software

Scoring model:

• Each criterion uses a 1–10 score for comparative shortlisting.
• Weighted Total is a directional estimate across this list, not a verified public rating.
• Use scoring to shortlist, then validate with a pilot using real labor rules, exceptions, and payroll exports.
• Treat must-haves like device support, labor policy complexity, and export requirements as filters before scoring.

Weights:

• Core features – 25%
• Ease of use – 15%
• Integrations and ecosystem – 15%
• Security and compliance – 10%
• Performance and reliability – 10%
• Support and community – 10%
• Price / value – 15%

Tool Name	Core (25%)	Ease (15%)	Integrations (15%)	Security (10%)	Performance (10%)	Support (10%)	Value (15%)	Weighted Total (0–10)
UKG Pro Workforce Management	9	6	8	7	8	7	5	7.15
UKG Ready	8	7	7	7	7	7	6	7.05
ADP Workforce Now	8	6	7	7	7	7	5	6.70
Workday Time Tracking	8	5	8	7	8	7	4	6.55
SAP SuccessFactors	8	5	8	7	8	7	4	6.55
Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM	8	5	8	7	8	7	4	6.55
Ceridian Dayforce	8	6	7	7	7	7	5	6.70
BambooHR	6	8	6	6	7	7	7	6.80
Deputy	7	8	6	6	7	7	7	7.05
When I Work	7	8	6	6	7	7	7	7.05

How to interpret these scores:

• Core rewards time capture options, exception handling, policy controls, approvals, and payroll readiness.
• Ease matters because employees must clock in and managers must approve without friction.
• Integrations matter when attendance data must flow into payroll and HR without manual cleanup.
• Value depends on workforce size, policy complexity, and how much payroll correction work you avoid.

---

Which Time and Attendance Software Is Right for You?

Solo / Freelancer

Solo users usually do not need time and attendance software. If you manage a small hourly team, choose a simple tool that supports easy clock-ins and approvals with minimal admin overhead.

SMB

SMBs need reliable clock-ins, manager approvals, and payroll-ready exports. Deputy and When I Work can fit well when scheduling and simple time capture are the primary needs. BambooHR can be useful when attendance must stay connected to HR workflows. If labor rules and exceptions become more complex, UKG Ready can be a stronger structured option.

Mid-Market

Mid-market organizations often need better exception handling, overtime controls, and consistent policies across teams. UKG Ready and Ceridian Dayforce can be good fits depending on policy complexity and payroll alignment needs. ADP Workforce Now becomes relevant when payroll integration is the top priority and approvals must be standardized.

Enterprise

Enterprises typically require strict labor rules, audit-ready controls, and enterprise integrations. UKG Pro Workforce Management fits complex multi-location operations needing strong policy enforcement. Workday Time Tracking, SAP SuccessFactors, and Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM fit best when your organization already uses those HR ecosystems and wants standardized governance. Ceridian Dayforce can fit where operational exception workflows and payroll readiness must be strong.

Budget vs Premium

• Budget-first teams should prioritize adoption, simple clock flows, and clean exports.
• Premium platforms are justified when policy complexity and exception handling reduce major payroll corrections and overtime waste.
• The biggest hidden cost is manual cleanup; prioritize tools that reduce rework.

Feature Depth vs Ease of Use

• If your pain is “missed punches and disputes,” prioritize exception workflows and self-service corrections.
• If your pain is “overtime and break violations,” prioritize rule configuration, alerts, and manager dashboards.
• If your pain is “payroll corrections,” prioritize approvals, locking concepts, and export reliability.

Integrations and Scalability

Attendance data becomes truly valuable when it flows cleanly into payroll and HR without manual mapping. Validate how pay codes, job roles, locations, and departments are structured and whether the tool supports consistent naming and governance. For scalability, test multi-location permissions, performance with many employees, device support, and how easy it is to roll out to new locations.

Security and Compliance Needs

Security and compliance details vary by plan and vendor. Focus on role-based access, audit-friendly change history concepts, and locked pay periods to protect data integrity. Also set internal policies for data retention, employee transparency, and how exceptions are handled fairly to maintain trust.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

1.What is time and attendance software used for?
It is used to capture working hours, manage exceptions, apply labor policies, and produce payroll-ready timecards with approvals and reports.

2.How is time and attendance different from time tracking?
Time tracking often focuses on project time and billing. Time and attendance focuses on clock-ins, attendance rules, exceptions, and payroll accuracy.

3.Do we need kiosks or mobile clock-ins?
It depends on your workforce. Field teams often need mobile. On-site teams may prefer kiosks. Some organizations use both.

4.How do these tools handle missed punches?
Many tools create an exception that employees request to correct and managers approve, with an audit history concept.

5.Can time and attendance tools reduce overtime?
Yes. They can alert managers early, enforce rules consistently, and provide reports that make overtime patterns visible.

6.What reports should we prioritize?
Overtime trends, attendance exceptions, late arrivals, break violations, and payroll correction volume by location and role.

7.How do we choose between a workforce suite and a simple attendance tool?
Choose workforce suites when policies and integrations are complex. Choose simpler tools when adoption and basic payroll exports are the main needs.

8.How do we ensure fairness and trust with attendance tracking?
Be transparent about policies, keep corrections easy, and ensure rules are applied consistently across teams and locations.

9.What should we test in a pilot?
Clock-in speed, exception handling, approval workflows, policy enforcement, payroll export accuracy, and manager reporting usefulness.

10.How long does rollout usually take?
It depends on policy complexity and integrations. Simple tools can roll out faster, while enterprise suites need more configuration and training.

---

Conclusion

Time and attendance software improves payroll accuracy, reduces disputes, and gives managers better control over staffing and labor costs. The best tool depends on how complex your labor rules are, how many locations you manage, and how closely time data must integrate with HR and payroll. Some organizations succeed with simple, mobile-first tools because employees adopt them quickly and managers can approve exceptions without friction. Others need enterprise platforms that enforce labor policies, support audits, and handle complex exception workflows at scale. A practical next step is to shortlist two or three tools, run a pilot using real shifts and real labor rules, and validate payroll export accuracy and exception handling speed. Focus on usability, consistent policy enforcement, and reporting that reduces overtime surprises and payroll cleanup work. When the workflow is simple and trusted, attendance data becomes a reliable foundation for fair operations.